What If I’m Not Ready to Talk About Everything Yet?

You don’t have to share everything in therapy right away. Starting therapy can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re unsure about opening up. The good news? Therapy is a process, not a race. You can set boundaries, take your time, and focus on what feels manageable.

Key Takeaways:

It’s normal to feel hesitant. Fear of judgment, past experiences, or emotional overwhelm can make sharing difficult.
Start small. Begin with less personal topics or use tools like journaling and mood tracking to ease into deeper conversations.
Set boundaries. You’re in control of what you discuss and when.
Virtual therapy helps. Options like secure messaging or turning off your camera let you share at your own pace.

You’re in charge of your therapy journey – take it step by step. Your comfort and readiness matter most.

Stalling out in session? Try these tips

Why You Might Feel Hesitant to Open Up

Feeling unsure about opening up in therapy? You’re not alone. A 2016 study revealed that 93% of people have lied to their therapist, with around 73% of those lies directly tied to therapy topics. This shows just how common it is to feel hesitant, and there are plenty of reasons that might explain this reluctance.

One of the biggest reasons is fear of judgment. You might worry your therapist will think less of you or see you as weak for sharing certain thoughts. If you’ve had negative experiences in the past – like being hurt by someone you trusted – it can make trusting someone new feel risky. Concerns about confidentiality are another common barrier. You may question whether your personal details will stay private. And then there’s the emotional weight – sometimes it’s just too overwhelming to share everything at once.

Your background can also play a role. In some families or communities, talking about feelings isn’t encouraged, which can make therapy feel unnatural or uncomfortable. On top of all this, financial stress can add pressure. With the average therapy session costing $178, it’s understandable to feel the need to make every moment count.

"It’s one thing to say, ‘the therapeutic relationship is essential,’ but there are some clients who really might not be willing to engage at all until they see certain things, especially nonjudgment, in their counselor." – Michael Tursi, LMHC in New York

Feeling Emotionally Exposed in Therapy

Therapy often asks for a level of vulnerability that can feel intense. Whether you’re sitting across from your therapist or talking through a screen, sharing your fears, embarrassing moments, or painful memories can feel overwhelming. According to the UK-based Mental Health Foundation, 74% of adults reported feeling overwhelmed or unable to cope at some point. When you’re already feeling this way, diving deeper into your emotions can seem impossible.

Many people start cautiously, sharing small pieces of their story to test their therapist’s response. If the reaction feels judgmental or dismissive, it’s only natural to pull back. This careful approach can actually be a smart way to build trust and ensure you feel safe before opening up further.

Sometimes, the emotional intensity of therapy can lead to emotional numbing – a kind of dissociation where your mind disconnects from feelings as a way to protect itself. This can make it tough to access or express your emotions during sessions. But don’t worry – there are ways to work through these feelings and communicate them to your therapist.

Virtual therapy has its own set of challenges and benefits when it comes to opening up. For one, the lack of in-person interaction can make it harder to pick up on your therapist’s body language, which might affect how connected or understood you feel. Technical glitches like audio delays or dropped connections can also disrupt the flow of a session, making vulnerable moments feel awkward.

Privacy at home can be another hurdle. You might worry about someone overhearing your session or feel self-conscious about your surroundings. While being in a familiar environment can be comforting, discussing deeply personal topics over video might still feel exposing.

On the other hand, virtual therapy offers some unique advantages. Being in your own space means you can create a setting that feels safe and comforting – whether that’s curling up in your favorite chair, keeping tissues handy, or even having your pet nearby for support. The physical distance of a video call can also act as a buffer, making it easier to start with smaller disclosures before diving into more personal topics. Plus, virtual therapy often provides alternative ways to communicate – like typing in a chat or sharing digital journal entries – giving you options if speaking feels too difficult. These features can help you set the pace and feel more in control of your therapy journey.

How to Gradually Open Up in Therapy

Opening up in therapy doesn’t happen all at once – it’s a gradual process that unfolds at your own pace. Here are some practical ways to ease into it, ensuring you feel safe and in control.

Setting Clear Boundaries

Boundaries are essential for creating a sense of safety and clarity during therapy sessions. Start by reflecting on what you’re comfortable sharing and what feels off-limits for now. For example, you might feel ready to talk about work-related stress but not yet prepared to delve into family issues. Or perhaps you’re open to discussing recent challenges but need more time before addressing deeper, past experiences. These choices are entirely valid and can help shape your early sessions.

"Boundaries can be anything, include anything, and change depending on the person/situation/time. All that matters is that they feel good to you." – Olivia Brouillette

Consider using your first session to express your expectations. You could say something like, “I want to focus on managing my current anxiety, but I’m not ready to explore its roots just yet.” This kind of direct communication helps your therapist tailor the process to your comfort level.

Keep in mind that boundaries aren’t static – they can change over time. What feels too sensitive to discuss today might feel easier to address as trust builds. Respect where you’re at right now, but allow room for growth as you become more comfortable.

Using Journaling and Mood-Tracking Apps

Digital tools can be a helpful bridge between sessions, offering insights into your emotions and experiences. Apps like Daylio and Moodnotes let you track your moods and daily activities, providing a clearer picture of patterns and triggers that might otherwise go unnoticed. These tools can help you identify topics to explore in therapy.

Helen McGillivray, a BABCP-accredited Cognitive Behavioral Therapist, highlights the value of mood tracking: “It helps you notice triggers and patterns that might otherwise go unnoticed”. For instance, you might discover that your anxiety spikes on certain days or in specific situations, like skipping meals or facing a busy Monday. These observations can serve as natural starting points for discussions with your therapist.

Journaling offers another way to reflect on your experiences. You don’t need to write perfectly – just jot down thoughts or use prompts to capture how you’re feeling. Both methods can make it easier to pinpoint what you’d like to talk about in your sessions.

Beginning with Less Personal Topics

Starting with everyday topics can help you ease into therapy while getting used to your therapist’s communication style. Sharing less personal aspects of your life, like recent events or daily routines, can feel more manageable at first.

For example, Sol Rapoport, a marriage and family therapist, suggests beginning sessions with a brief recap of your week: “Therapy sessions really are meant to be as tailored as possible to what you need at any given moment”. You might mention a tough day at work, a meaningful conversation with a friend, or simply how you’re feeling in that moment.

Discussing safe topics like sleep patterns, work challenges, or even small wins from your week can provide valuable insights into your mental health without feeling overwhelming. Highlighting positive experiences or strengths can also help build confidence in your relationship with your therapist.

As you grow more comfortable, you can gradually transition to topics that feel more personal. The key is to set your own pace – your therapist is there to support and guide you through what you’re ready to explore.

sbb-itb-e6bfb1d

How to Tell Your Therapist You’re Not Ready

Feeling hesitant about certain topics in therapy? You’re not alone. Many people experience this, and it’s an entirely normal part of the process. In fact, most therapists appreciate honest feedback – it helps them better understand how to support you.

What to Say When You Need More Time

Using "I" statements can be a great way to express your feelings without making assumptions about your therapist’s expectations. This approach keeps the conversation respectful while ensuring your needs are clear.

Here are some examples of what you could say:

If you’re not ready to dive into a specific topic: "I’m not ready to discuss my family relationships right now. Can we focus on managing my current stress levels instead?"
When a discussion feels overwhelming: "This topic feels like too much for me right now. Can we slow down and approach it in a different way?"
To set boundaries for your session: "Talking about my childhood feels too intense at the moment. I’d like to work on strategies for dealing with my daily anxiety instead."
If you need a different method: "I’m struggling to say this out loud. Would it be okay if I wrote down my thoughts for our next session?"

"Therapy is and can be designed to the exact way you want it to be. It is your time that you are paying for, and you deserve to have it tailored to your needs and wants. Don’t be afraid of speaking up." – Genea, Lives in Pittsburgh, PA

It’s okay to acknowledge your hesitation. You might say something like, "I know I should probably talk about this, but I’m not feeling ready yet. Can we ease into it gradually?" If speaking up feels difficult, consider jotting down your thoughts beforehand and bringing them to your session. This can help you organize your feelings and communicate them more effectively.

These straightforward statements create an opportunity to work with your therapist on a plan that aligns with your comfort level.

Working Together on a Therapy Plan That Fits You

Therapy is meant to be a safe and supportive space. Open communication plays a key role in shaping sessions that meet your individual needs. The process is a partnership – your therapist is there to help you find approaches that feel right for you. If something isn’t working, don’t hesitate to bring it up.

Building on the importance of setting boundaries, here are some ways to collaborate with your therapist for a more tailored experience:

Talk about pacing: If the sessions feel rushed or too slow, let your therapist know. For instance, "I feel like we’re moving too quickly through topics. Could we take more time with each one?"
Explore alternative methods: If verbalizing your thoughts is tough, ask about other options like written exercises or sharing notes between sessions.
Set clear goals together: Work with your therapist to define short-term objectives, such as, "I want to feel more comfortable discussing my anxiety triggers" or "I’d like to improve my sleep habits before tackling deeper issues."
Give feedback regularly: Letting your therapist know how you’re feeling about the process can help them adjust their approach as needed.

This collaborative effort ensures that therapy remains centered on your needs.

"The therapeutic hour is for you, and only you. Bringing in feelings you have from outside is only one part of the equation; feelings you have inside the room, even negative ones, are equally good material. If you’re seeing the right therapist, they’ll want to hear about it all, and they’ll still have positive regard for you when your time is up." – Melissa Stanger, LMSW

If virtual therapy feels awkward or impersonal, bring this up with your therapist. They can help address challenges like technical issues or privacy concerns to make your sessions more comfortable and engaging.

Consistency is key to making progress, so work with your therapist to establish a schedule and approach that feels sustainable. The ultimate goal is to create a therapeutic relationship where you feel heard, supported, and in charge of your healing journey.

Using Virtual Therapy to Go at Your Own Pace

Virtual therapy offers a unique opportunity for those who need time to feel comfortable opening up. With online therapy, you decide what to share and when to share it.

One of the standout benefits of virtual sessions is the ability to move at your own speed. In fact, virtual therapy boasts a 16% higher completion rate compared to traditional in-person therapy. Being in your own environment gives you greater control over your comfort and surroundings, making it easier to manage the intensity of sessions and ensuring you feel secure throughout the process.

Virtual therapy platforms come with tools designed to ease the pressure of opening up. These features allow you to stay in control while still engaging meaningfully with your therapist.

One helpful feature is camera control. If certain topics feel too vulnerable, you can turn off your camera entirely or adjust the video settings to show less of yourself. Some people find that tweaking their video view makes conversations feel less overwhelming while still maintaining a connection with their therapist.

Another option is secure messaging portals. These allow you to communicate with your therapist at any time, day or night. If you’re not ready to verbalize your feelings, you can share them through written messages instead. This flexibility ensures you can express yourself in a way that feels comfortable.

Virtual therapy platforms also offer a variety of communication methods, including video calls, phone sessions, emails, and text messaging. These tools are HIPAA-compliant, ensuring your privacy is protected while giving you the freedom to choose the method that works best for you.

Creating a dedicated therapy space at home can further enhance your sense of control. By setting up a specific area for your sessions, you can establish a clear boundary that supports emotional focus and reinforces your ownership of the process.

Another advantage of virtual therapy is the ability to adjust the emotional intensity of sessions. You can step back from the screen, look away when needed, or even mute your audio temporarily to collect your thoughts. These small adjustments can make difficult conversations more manageable.

Privacy and Comfort in the US

Beyond its technological perks, virtual therapy reshapes the balance of privacy and comfort in mental health care. For many Americans, the stigma surrounding mental health remains a barrier, but online therapy helps address these concerns. The confidentiality of virtual sessions, combined with the comfort of being at home, can ease anxiety about seeking help.

"Privacy plays a vital role in therapy. It creates a safe space where you can explore your deepest thoughts without fear."
– East Coast Telepsychiatry

The shift toward virtual therapy is widely embraced. According to the APA‘s 2021 Covid-19 Practitioner Impact Survey, 96% of psychologists reported treating patients remotely. This growing acceptance has helped normalize mental health care and made it more accessible.

Virtual therapy also empowers patients in ways traditional settings often don’t. It’s easier to ask questions, challenge your therapist, or express disagreement when you’re in a more relaxed, familiar environment. Plus, virtual therapy can save up to 39% compared to in-person sessions, making it a more affordable option for many.

For those who worry about privacy at home, there are creative solutions. In some areas, therapists and organizations partner with local libraries, community colleges, or medical centers to offer private spaces for virtual therapy. As Ashley Batastini, PhD, explains:

"For vulnerable or underserved clients, this task may prove more difficult. One possibility psychologists might consider is establishing partnerships with local community organizations or other spaces that offer private, centralized, and clean spaces for clients to attend sessions, such as libraries, medical centers, community colleges, or courthouses."
– Ashley Batastini, PhD, University of Memphis

Ultimately, virtual therapy gives you the flexibility to tailor the experience to your needs. Whether it’s adjusting your environment, choosing how to communicate, or finding privacy solutions, you can access the support you need without compromising your comfort or safety.

Conclusion: Taking Control of Your Therapy Experience

You are in charge of your therapy journey. Taking things at a pace that feels right for you is essential for creating a safe and effective process. Studies highlight that readiness to change plays a significant role in therapy outcomes, with one meta-analysis showing a mean effect size of d = .46 between readiness to change and treatment success.

Tools like setting boundaries, journaling, and mood tracking give you the power to engage with therapy on your terms. As Nedra Glover Tawwab wisely points out, "Setting limits won’t disrupt a healthy relationship". This principle doesn’t just apply to personal relationships – it’s just as relevant to the dynamic you share with your therapist and the therapeutic process itself. These strategies tie back to earlier discussions about gradually opening up in therapy.

When you clearly and consistently communicate your boundaries, you’re not slowing down your healing. Instead, you’re laying the groundwork for authentic growth. Counseling Psychologist Olivia Brouillette explains it well: "Boundaries can be anything, include anything, and change depending on the person/situation/time. All that matters is that they feel good to you".

Virtual therapy offers a unique advantage in helping you maintain control over how and when you share. Whether it’s adjusting your environment, choosing to keep your camera off, or using different communication channels, these options let you tailor therapy to your comfort level. This doesn’t mean avoiding tough conversations forever – it means approaching them when you feel ready and supported.

Progress in therapy looks different for everyone. Some people dive in headfirst, while others take their time to open up. Both approaches are valid and can lead to meaningful growth. What matters most is showing up consistently and honoring your emotional readiness.

As you move forward in your therapy journey, trust your instincts about when to explore deeper topics. Your sense of your own emotional capacity is a strength, not a barrier. Taking control of your therapy experience reflects a level of self-awareness and advocacy that goes far beyond the therapy room.

FAQs

What should I do if I’m not ready to talk about certain things in therapy?

It’s completely normal to feel hesitant about diving into certain topics in therapy right away. If something feels too overwhelming, you can let your therapist know by saying something like, “I’m not ready to talk about that yet” or “I need a little more time before I can address this.” Setting these boundaries not only helps your therapist understand where you’re at but also ensures you feel safe and supported during your sessions.

If you’re not sure how to get started, tools like journaling or mood-tracking apps can be really helpful. They allow you to organize your thoughts and pinpoint smaller, more manageable topics to begin discussing. Therapy is your personal journey, and it’s important to move at a pace that feels comfortable for you.

What can I do if I feel too overwhelmed to talk about everything in therapy?

Feeling overwhelmed during therapy? That’s a common experience, and it’s okay to take things at your own pace. If diving into everything feels too much, start small. Share bits about your daily life or focus on topics that feel easier to discuss. This step-by-step approach can help you build trust and gradually ease into more personal conversations.

It might also help to use grounding techniques, like mindfulness or deep breathing, during sessions. These can help you stay calm and manage overwhelming emotions. And remember, your therapist is there to support you. If you’re feeling uneasy, let them know – they can adjust the pace to match what feels right for you.

What if I’m not ready to talk about everything in therapy?

It’s completely natural to feel a bit unsure about opening up in therapy, especially when you’re just getting started. One of the benefits of virtual therapy is that you can connect with your therapist from the comfort of your own space. This familiar setting can ease some of the initial anxiety and help you feel more at ease.

You don’t have to dive into everything right away. Start small – share what feels manageable for you. Tools like journaling or using mood-tracking apps can help you sort through your thoughts beforehand, making it easier to pinpoint what you’re ready to talk about. Be honest with your therapist about how you’re feeling; they’re there to support you and will adjust to your pace. Therapy is a process, so give yourself permission to take it step by step.